Sunday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Wednesday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Thursday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Friday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday
7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Call Anytime: (718)858-6368
At Atlantic Bagels Cafe, we’re passionate about crafting warm, freshly baked bagels and quality NYC favorites that bring our Brooklyn community together. Under new ownership, we’ve revived this neighborhood gem with friendly service, bold flavors, and a welcoming space where every visit feels like coming home.
See our most popular items
Here’s a sneak peek of the items our customers can’t stop talking about
What our guests are saying
I enjoyed a warm freshly baked classic plain bagel with butter and it was delicious. My partner and I also shared the kale salad (large portions!) and it was also super yummy. Will definitely visit again and try one of the signature sandwiches.
Jenene C
This place is so good, how did I not know about it? Definitely a dark horse contender for the best bagels in NYC. How did no one tell me about their lard bread bagel??? The staff was very professional and friendly and seemed to genuinely enjoy being there.
Trevor McPhee
In case you missed it, Atlantic Bagels is under new ownership! Ina and her team have done an amazing job at reviving this neighborhood spot. It’s now a warm, inviting space with fantastic bagels (classics as well as interesting new flavors like raisin fennel) and service. The prices are also super reasonable compared to many of the other bagel shops nearby. If you haven’t been back in some time because the old spot wasn’t your thing, I recommend giving Atlantic Bagels 2.0 a shot!
Todd Needle
New (local, independent!!) ownership has done an amazing job revamping the space and menu while maintaining the same affordable prices. Highly recommend the fried chicken sandwich (I crave this… truly so good), and the grab and go salads are excellent… as well as the bagels, of course!
Ellie Cody
Baked Fresh, Crafted with Care
At Atlantic Bagels Cafe, every bagel is crafted with the warmth of family tradition and the passion of Ina and her team, who revived this beloved neighborhood spot to share their love for fresh, honest food with Brooklyn’s community. Here, each bite carries the care of generations and the joy of creating a welcoming place where friends and neighbors gather to savor simple, soulful flavors.